Behind the stories

A fabric with a complicated history

Illustration for the story: BREAKING: Progressive Activists Claim Wearing Clothes Made from Cotton Is 'Problematic,' Urge Nation to Dress in Tote Bags
0Real people named
12Slides in the carousel
4 minRead

The story has no single news hook. It answers a recurring online pattern: campaigns that ask people to feel guilty about everyday objects while changing very little about them.

The Smattering DeskBehind the stories

Every Smattering story starts from a real event and goes exactly one step further. Here is the step, and the line we did not cross.

“Even wool raises questions. Some lambs are born dark and then turn white. What is that telling our kids?”

The real news2023, Atlanta, GA

The history of cotton in America is brutal and real, and the story says so plainly in its first section. The target is the performance of outrage, not the history.

The escalationOne step further

Our activists ask the nation to stop wearing cotton and dress in tote bags instead. The statement arrives as a twelve-slide carousel, posted from bed in a cotton hoodie.

Where we drew the line

The activists are invented and nobody real is named. We kept the history accurate and pointed the joke at the posting, not at the past.

Read itThe story itself

The full piece is labeled as satire at the top and the bottom of the page. If you share it, share the link, so the label travels with the joke.

Read the story

4 min read, Culture desk.

Open the story

Get the next one

Free in your inbox once or twice a week.

See plans